Basic vocabulary: Difference between revisions

From FrathWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 13: Line 13:


===Yakhontov list===
===Yakhontov list===
A brief 35-word list developed by S. Yakhontov that was used by the Russian Nostratics school as a preliminary approximation of the stablest basic vocabulary, prior to the development of the Swadesh-50 list.
A brief 35-word list developed by Sergei Yakhontov that was used by the Russian Nostratics school as a preliminary approximation of the stablest basic vocabulary, prior to the development of the Swadesh-50 list.


==Comparison==
==Comparison==

Revision as of 08:54, 11 August 2014

Basic vocabulary is a concept that is frequently encountered in __.

Lists for historical comparison

Swadesh-50 list

Distinct "stability quotients" have been determined for each of the Swadesh-100 entries by Sergei Starostin. On this basis, George Starostin proposes establishing a shortened version of the list for surveying the genetical affiliation of languages. For reasons of practicality, he excludes also a number of relatively stable word roots that show other issues:

  • the pronouns "this" and "that": the structure of demonstrative pronoun systems in the world's languages may vary, and short monosyllabic demonstrative roots are prone to accidental similarities
  • 'liver', a word frequently unrecorded in superficial surveys
  • 'fish', a concept frequently unknown in desert communities
  • 'neck', "breast": prone to sound-symbolism and polysemy (versus "throat" and "chest")
  • 'full', "stand", "give": prone to synonymy

These nine words are substituted with three body parts ('foot', 'horn', 'head'), two universal food items ('meat', 'egg'), two semantically better-defined verbs ('to kill', 'to hear') as well as 'black', 'night'.

Yakhontov list

A brief 35-word list developed by Sergei Yakhontov that was used by the Russian Nostratics school as a preliminary approximation of the stablest basic vocabulary, prior to the development of the Swadesh-50 list.

Comparison

Abbreviations:

  • LJ: the Leipzig-Jakarta list
  • Sw50, 100, 200: various versions of the Swadesh list
  • Y: the Yakhontov list
Lexeme Semantic area LJ Sw50 Sw100 Sw200 Y
we pronoun
two numeral
I pronoun
eye body part
thou pronoun
who pronoun
fire nature
tongue body part
stone nature
name
hand body part
what pronoun
die verb
heart body part
drink verb
dog animal
louse animal
moon
fingernail body part
blood body part
one numeral
tooth body part