Basic vocabulary: Difference between revisions
(some comparision) |
|||
Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
===Swadesh-50 list=== | ===Swadesh-50 list=== | ||
Distinct "stability quotients" have been determined for each of the Swadesh-100 entries by Sergei Starostin. On this basis, George Starostin proposes establishing a shortened version of the list for surveying the genetical affiliation of languages. For reasons of practicality, he excludes also a number of relatively stable word roots that show other issues: | |||
* the pronouns "this" and "that": the structure of demonstrative pronoun systems in the world's languages may vary, and short monosyllabic demonstrative roots are prone to accidental similarities | |||
* 'liver', a word frequently unrecorded in superficial surveys | |||
* 'fish', a concept frequently unknown in desert communities | |||
* 'neck', "breast": prone to sound-symbolism and polysemy (versus "throat" and "chest") | |||
* 'full', "stand", "give": prone to synonymy | |||
These nine words are substituted with three body parts ('foot', 'horn', 'head'), two universal food items ('meat', 'egg'), two semantically better-defined verbs ('to kill', 'to hear') as well as 'black', 'night'. | |||
===Yakhontov list=== | ===Yakhontov list=== |
Revision as of 08:52, 11 August 2014
Basic vocabulary is a concept that is frequently encountered in __.
Lists for historical comparison
Swadesh-50 list
Distinct "stability quotients" have been determined for each of the Swadesh-100 entries by Sergei Starostin. On this basis, George Starostin proposes establishing a shortened version of the list for surveying the genetical affiliation of languages. For reasons of practicality, he excludes also a number of relatively stable word roots that show other issues:
- the pronouns "this" and "that": the structure of demonstrative pronoun systems in the world's languages may vary, and short monosyllabic demonstrative roots are prone to accidental similarities
- 'liver', a word frequently unrecorded in superficial surveys
- 'fish', a concept frequently unknown in desert communities
- 'neck', "breast": prone to sound-symbolism and polysemy (versus "throat" and "chest")
- 'full', "stand", "give": prone to synonymy
These nine words are substituted with three body parts ('foot', 'horn', 'head'), two universal food items ('meat', 'egg'), two semantically better-defined verbs ('to kill', 'to hear') as well as 'black', 'night'.
Yakhontov list
A brief 35-word list developed by S. Yakhontov that was used by the Russian Nostratics school as a preliminary approximation of the stablest basic vocabulary, prior to the development of the Swadesh-50 list.
Comparison
Abbreviations:
- LJ: the Leipzig-Jakarta list
- Sw50, 100, 200: various versions of the Swadesh list
- Y: the Yakhontov list
Lexeme | Semantic area | LJ | Sw50 | Sw100 | Sw200 | Y |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
we | pronoun | √ | ||||
two | numeral | √ | ||||
I | pronoun | √ | ||||
eye | body part | √ | ||||
thou | pronoun | √ | ||||
who | pronoun | √ | ||||
fire | nature | √ | ||||
tongue | body part | √ | ||||
stone | nature | √ | ||||
name | √ | |||||
hand | body part | √ | ||||
what | pronoun | √ | ||||
die | verb | √ | ||||
heart | body part | √ | ||||
drink | verb | √ | ||||
dog | animal | √ | ||||
louse | animal | √ | ||||
moon | √ | |||||
fingernail | body part | √ | ||||
blood | body part | √ | ||||
one | numeral | √ | ||||
tooth | body part | √ | ||||