Proto-Samic: Difference between revisions

From FrathWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 158: Line 158:
| 7
| 7
| ||
| ||
| || single root
| ||style="color:gray"| single root
|-
|-
! n
! n
Line 166: Line 166:
| 16
| 16
| ||
| ||
| || style="background:#ffffe0"| two roots
| || 2-3 roots
|-
|-
! ŋ
! ŋ
| || || || || style="background:#ffc8c0"| ŋk
| || || || || style="background:#ffc8c0"| ŋk
| ŋs ||
| ŋs ||
| ŋm || || ||
| (ŋm) || || ||
| 9
| 9
| ||
| ||
| || style="background:#fff0c0"| 3-4 roots
| || style="background:#ffffe0"| 4-6 roots
|-
|-
! rowspan="5" valign="center" style="background:#f0f0f0"| [[Plosive|P]]
! rowspan="5" valign="center" style="background:#f0f0f0"| [[Plosive|P]]
Line 185: Line 185:
| 7
| 7
| ||
| ||
| || style="background:#ffc8c0"| 5-6 roots
| || style="background:#fff0c0"| 7-10 roots
|-
|-
! t
! t
| || tt || || || style="background:#fff0c0"| tk
| || tt || || || style="background:#fff0c0"| tk
| || ||
| colspan="2" rowspan="3" align="center" valign="center" style="background:#f0f0f0"| N/A
| ||
| colspan="3" rowspan="3" align="center" valign="center" style="background:#f0f0f0"| N/A
| tv ||
| tv ||
| 3
| 3
| ||
| ||
| || style="background:#f0c0f0"| 10+ roots
| || style="background:#ffc8c0"| 11-15 roots
|-
|-
! c
! c
| || || cc || || style="background:#ffffe0"| ck
| || || cc || || style="background:#ffffe0"| ck
| || ||
| ||
| ||
| ||
| 3
| 3
| ||
| ||
| || style="background:#c0f0ff"| Most suspiciously none
| || style="background:#f0c0f0"| 16-20 roots
|-
|-
! ć
! ć
| || || || ćć || ćk
| || || || ćć || ćk
| || ||
| ||
| ||
| ćm || || ||
|
| ||
| ||
| ćm || || ||
| || style="background:#c0f0ff"|  
|-
|-
! k
! k
Line 219: Line 218:
| || || || (kŋ)  
| || || || (kŋ)  
| 12
| 12
| || Lehtisalo reconstructs *ŋv rather than *kv.<br/>"*kŋ" is likely to be erroneous
| ||
|-
|-
! rowspan="2" valign="center" style="background:#f0f0f0"| [[Sibilant|Sbl]]
! rowspan="2" valign="center" style="background:#f0f0f0"| [[Sibilant|Sbl]]
Line 292: Line 291:
| 7 || 1 || 4
| 7 || 1 || 4
|}
|}
* "*kŋ" is likely to be erroneous:


{|
{|
|+ '''Three-consonant clusters'''
|+ '''Geminate clusters'''
|-
|-
! 2nd →<br/>1st ↓
! 2nd →<br/>1st ↓
Line 303: Line 300:
|-
|-
! m
! m
| mpp || || || ||
| style="color:gray"| mpp || || || ||
| 1
|-
|-
! l
! l
| lpp || ltt || || lćć || lkk
| lpp || ltt || || lćć || style="background:#fff0c0"| lkk <!--8-->
| 16
|-
|-
! r
! r
| || rtt || rcc || rćć || rkk
| || style="background:#fff0c0"| rtt (9) || rcc || rćć || style="background:#ffffe0"| rkk <!--5-->
| 18
|-
|-
! v
! v
| || || || || vkk
| || || || || style="background:#fff0c0"| vkk <!--7-->
| 7
|-
|-
! j
! j
| || jtt || jcc || || jkk
| || style="background:#ffffe0"| jtt <!--6-->||style="color:gray"| jcc || || jkk
| 10
|-
|-
! ∑
! ∑
| || || || ||
| 3 || 18 || 3 || 5 || 23
|}
|}
==Comments==
* *-tr- in IE loans is substituted by metathesized *-rtt-.
* *ðð is found in two words and may have been phonetically [-θð-].
* I would reconstruct *kv rather than *ŋv for the set of words showing WS *-vk-, ES *-vv-. This allows setting up a constraint against nasal+semivowel clusters & is supported by Scandinavian loan etymologies.
* Some unsecure clusters (in parentheses) may result from variable adoption of substrate loanwords:
** "*ŋm" is based on a single word showing WS *-ŋ-, Inari -ŋ-, -vŋ- in rest of ES.
** "*kŋ" is based on two words showing NWS *-ŋ-, versus Peninsular ES *-vŋ-. Inari and Skolt Sami have -ŋ- for the first, -vŋ- for the 2nd.




[[Category:Sound changes]]
[[Category:Sound changes]]

Revision as of 11:06, 25 April 2013

Proto-Samic is the reconstructed last common ancestor of the Samic languages. It was spoken in the 1st millennium CE in the area of modern-day northern Finland. (If extinct southern languages are included, this dating will likely become both older and more southern. Stem-group para-Samic languages have from toponymic evidence once been spoken as far south as the Baltic coast)

Sound changes from Proto-Uralic

Possibly original:

  • e → ɪ / _Ci (see )
  • e → e / _{j w x} (ie. does not become *ɪ → *ɤ)
  • Vx → Və → Vː / _C

Proto-Uralic to Pre-Samic (≈ "Finno-Volgaic")

Shared with Finnic & Mordvinic

  • ë → a
  • ðʲ → ð (also lʲ → l, if it exists separately; note that other palatals remain)
    • NB: Sammallahti posits ðʲ → θ / V_C (*käðʲwa "weasel" → *káθwé → NS gádfe - but can this be ruled out for ð? Cf. *kotwa > IS kuáđfi)

Shared with Mordvinic

  • ü → i (feeds the next changes)
  • i → iː / _{j x}
  • u → uː / _{w x}
  • i u → ɪ ʊ (*iː *uː remain) (also shared with Ugric, Nenets!)

Pre-Samic to Proto-Samic

  • V → Vː / [-HIGH] (also shared with Nenets!)

a-umlaut

  • eː äː oː → ea aː oa / _C{aː, oː} (note that this *aː is distinct from *ɑː!)
  • x, ŋ → w / _t (*xt by now only occurring in newer derivativs/loans)
  • ? ŋ → w / _ć (*(k/s)lāvćā ~ H. légy, or ONo kleggi)

Spirant fortition

  • ś x → ć k / _V
  • PS *ć (written also *č) is perhaps describable as a palatal stop, so we may be dealing with a process [sʲ ~ ɕ] → [ç] → [c]. Note that original *s *š remain sibilants!
  • PS *ś (likewise also written *š) remains elsewhere
    • śj, sj → śś
    • ðj → ðś
  • ð → θ / #_ (South/Ume h-, elsewhere merges with *t-)

Fronting of postalveolars

  • tʃ ʃ <č š> → ts s <c s>

'Preaspiration

  • Pː → ʰPː (both grades; affricates as well)

Popular areal changes

  • w → ∅ / _{y u o} (shared with Finnic, Mordvinic, Mari)
  • j → ∅ / _{i e} (not sure about the distribution of this)
  • w → v (even syllable-finally)

Raising & epenthesis (first two shared with North Finnic but obviously non-genetic)

  • äː ɑː → eː oː / [+STR]
  • ∅ → v / #_oː
  • ∅ → j / #_eː
  • aː → eː / [-STR]
         except remains / [-STR]_ɪ
          → iː / [-STR]_j
  • oː → uː / [-STR]_ɪ

Gradation could be described around here?

Cluster stuff

  • tr → rtt (in loans)
  • k → v / _j (*rōvjē *vōvjē, possibly *tāvjē if not from Fi. *taɣja; South S. has -kś-)
         _l (*keavlē *kōvlē- *nāvlē *tōvlē; *ćīvlē with *ük > *iv > *īv ?!)
         _ń (*ćóvné)
  • t → r / _n (*vōrnē-; but PGmc *bodam → *ponné, later loan?)
  • n → s / _s (*kāssē *koassē *kōssē *peassē *vōssē)
  • ŋ → k / _s (*jōksɤ)

Centralization (a late change - consider eg the northern Lappland toponym *ɤnārɤš → Finnish Inari)

  • ɪ ʊ → ɤ o

There may have also been a high lax unrounded back vowel (see ô_a). A merger into that might provide the motivation for the unusual back reflex of PU *i.


This results in the following inventory:

  • long vowels */iː eː ea aː oa oː uː/ <ī ē ea ā oa ō ū>
  • short vowels */ɤ o/ <ë o>

/ea oa/ are traditionally analyzed as [ɛː ɔː] rather than [ea oa], however I'm at a loss to explain how would *ɑː end up as *oː in that case.

The shortening of iː uː → i u, the backing of e → ɤ and the diphthongization eː oː → ie uo (when stress'd) may postdate Proto-Samic; the former two have bimoraic/front reflexes /ij uv e/ in South Samic. At any rate, as eg. *a *e in Scandinavian loans ends up as *ā *ē, the "long" vowels must've been the unmarked series.

Sound changes to individual Sami languages

Proto-Samic to Proto-Western Samic

  • preaspiration spreds to strong grade simple stops/affricates
  • ŋm → mː
  • ŋv → vk ([vg̊]) (versus East *vː, so why not just PS *vː?)
  • NP → Bː (also affricates; later also in Inari, Skolt, Kemi, possibly South; cf. Scandinavian)
  • ś → jʰ / _{n t k} (counterfeeds medial voicing in South)
  • Nː → ʔN (orthographic <bm dn>; counterfeeds gemination in South)

PWS to South Samic

  • θ ð → h r
  • Short vowel split
    • ë o ī ū → ɨC uC ɨj uv / open 1st syllable (+ gemination after *ë *o)
    • ë o ī ū → a a ɨ u / closed 1st syllable
    • Possibly works better if preceding the lowering *i *u → *ë *o (!!)
  • ē ea → ië ie
  • ē ë ō → ie e u [-STR] (& more complications, but this'll do)
  • umlauts
    • ɨ u a → i y ä / _C*ie
    • a → ä / _C*u (if from *ë)
    • ɨ a → y o / _v
  • medial voicing of plain stops

Proto-W Samic to Proto-NW Samic

Comprises Northern, Lule & Pite Sami.

  • ɤ → ɑ (also Inari; some dialects historically had ɤ → e / _C*{i u})
  • m → b̥ / _P[-LAB] (*b̥d̥ *b̥ć̥ remain distinct from *pt *pć; also *ćɤmkɤ → *ćɑpkɑ; partially also in South)
      nbsp; nbsp; →
  • N₁ → P / _N₂ (ie. nm mn → tn pm)
  • "kŋ" → ʔŋ (*tōkŋɤ, *ākŋō; South ŋ, Inari/Kildin/ vŋ, Skolt ŋː. Mari/Komi #tum-?)
  • ck ćk ćm → sk śk śm (also Ume, Inari, Kemi, northern Skolt; check other affricate clusters?)
  • strong grade of singletons merges with weak grade of geminates (also Inari, Skolt, Akkala; mostly also Ume, but four degrees attested dialectally!!)
  • repeat: Nː → ʔN (later in Ume where 4 lengths attested; perhaps not common West Samic at all)
  • N → ʔN / r_
  • p → β / _ʰk (strong grade)
  • θ → t / #_

PNWS to Lule-Pite

  • vj → jv (sporadically in North, Ume, South; or does this go before *kj > vj?)
  • ð → d̥ / C_

PNWS to North Sami

  • ie ea oa uo → iː eː oː uː / _C*V[+hi], further → i e o u / _hC etc.
  • eː oː → i u / [-STR]

(other vowel stuff probs too?)

  • k → ɣ / _{s ʰt ʰć} (strong grade; also East, Lule)
  • p b̥ → k / _{t c ć s ś} (both grades)
    • further → ɣ in most dialects
  • ɣ → v / _C
    • Sammallahti claims v → k / _S, strong grade, but what's wrong with retention + analogy on *vs *vś?
  • p [b̥] → β / _{r l ð}
    • further βr βð → rv ðβ
    • also Inari, partially Skolt, Lule
  • N → T / Vs_, with sń → st
    • spred irregularly to other idioms
    • sm generally retain'd
  • t [d̥] → ð / V_V (weak grade; Finnish influence? also Inari, Skolt)
  • lm rd̥ jg̊ vs → lmː rd̥ː jg̊ː vsː (wtf?)
  • θv → ðf (wtf? could be handled better, I'm sure)

Medial consonant clusters

Data extracted from Juhani Lehtisalo: Yhteissaamelainen sanasto (SUST vol. 200)

(proper colors/numbers TBA)

Two-consonant clusters
2nd →
1st ↓
p t c ć k s ś ð l r v j m n ń ŋ Notes Frequency color code
N m mp mt mc N/A N/A mm mn 7 single root
n nt nc nn 16 2-3 roots
ŋ ŋk ŋs (ŋm) 9 4-6 roots
P p pp pt pc pk ps pl pr N/A 7 7-10 roots
t tt tk N/A N/A tv 3 11-15 roots
c cc ck 3 16-20 roots
ć ćć ćk ćm
k kt kc kk ks kl kv (kŋ) 12
Sbl s st sk ss N/A sv sm sn 2
ś śt śk śś śm śn 5
Spr ð ðk ðð ðv ðŋ 2
L l lp lt lk ls ll lv lj lm ln 25
r rp rt rk rs rr rv rj rm rn 10
sV v vt vc vk vs vl vr vv vj vn 6
j jp jt jk js jl jr jv jj jm jn 6
4 19 7 37 7 10 (1) 3 1 0 6 5 7 1 4
Geminate clusters
2nd →
1st ↓
pp tt cc ćć kk
m mpp 1
l lpp ltt lćć lkk 16
r rtt (9) rcc rćć rkk 18
v vkk 7
j jtt jcc jkk 10
3 18 3 5 23

Comments

  • *-tr- in IE loans is substituted by metathesized *-rtt-.
  • *ðð is found in two words and may have been phonetically [-θð-].
  • I would reconstruct *kv rather than *ŋv for the set of words showing WS *-vk-, ES *-vv-. This allows setting up a constraint against nasal+semivowel clusters & is supported by Scandinavian loan etymologies.
  • Some unsecure clusters (in parentheses) may result from variable adoption of substrate loanwords:
    • "*ŋm" is based on a single word showing WS *-ŋ-, Inari -ŋ-, -vŋ- in rest of ES.
    • "*kŋ" is based on two words showing NWS *-ŋ-, versus Peninsular ES *-vŋ-. Inari and Skolt Sami have -ŋ- for the first, -vŋ- for the 2nd.